Tag Archives: Benchmarks

Things I Worry About (13): Every Plan Commits Prohibited Transactions and the Cornell University Decision

Key Takeaways

  • When an ERISA governed retirement plan engages and pays service providers, such as advisors and recordkeepers, it commits a prohibited transaction.
  • However, if the plan fiduciaries satisfy the conditions of an exemption (which, in this case, would be the 408(b)(2) statutory exemption), the prohibited transaction is exempt, that is, it becomes permissible.
  • If the conditions of the exemption (e.g., reasonable arrangement and reasonable compensation) are not satisfied, the plan fiduciaries have engaged in a nonexempt prohibited transaction that can be the basis for an adverse finding in a DOL investigation or the basis for a lawsuit.
  • The recent Supreme Court decision in Cunningham v. Cornell held that the burden of proof for determining whether the conditions of 408(b)(2) were satisfied are on the plan fiduciaries, meaning that plaintiffs’ attorneys can simply allege that the fiduciaries hired service providers and then the fiduciaries must prove that they satisfied the conditions of the exemption.

In an ERISA fiduciary breach lawsuit, plaintiffs’ attorneys must allege actions by fiduciaries that violated the law’s fiduciary standards and then, at trial, they must prove those facts. However, the Supreme Court’s decision in Cunningham v. Cornell University turns that process on its head by holding that the burden of proof for an exemption from prohibited transactions is not on the plaintiffs, but instead is on the defendants—the plan fiduciaries. As a result,  lawsuits that allege prohibited transactions are more likely to proceed to trial and perhaps increase the risk of loss for plan fiduciaries. More on this later in the article.

Continue reading Things I Worry About (13): Every Plan Commits Prohibited Transactions and the Cornell University Decision

Share

Best Practices for Plan Sponsors #11

Lessons Learned from Litigation (#4)—The ABB Case

This is the eleventh in a series of articles about Best Practices for Plan Sponsors. To be clear, “best practices” are not the same as legal requirements. Instead, they are about better ways to manage retirement plans. In many cases, though, “best practices” also are good risk management tools because they should exceed legal standards, address areas of concern, or anticipate future developments as retirement plans and expectations evolve.

Plan sponsors should be aware of the latest trends in fiduciary litigation to help manage the risk of being sued and, if sued, the risk of being liable. In my past three plan sponsor posts, Best Practices for Plan Sponsors #8, #9, and #10, I discussed the lessons learned from the conditions in the settlement agreements for the Anthem, Vanderbilt and BB&T cases. This article—about the ABB settlement agreement—is another example of the importance of using appropriate share classes and the  monitoring of compensation of service providers . . . and more.

Continue reading Best Practices for Plan Sponsors #11

Share

Best Practices for Plan Sponsors #10

Lessons Learned from Litigation (#3)—The BB&T Case

This is the tenth in a series of articles about Best Practices for Plan Sponsors. To be clear, “best practices” are not the same as legal requirements. Instead, they are about better ways to manage retirement plans. In many cases, though, “best practices” also are good risk management tools because they should exceed legal standards, address areas of concern, or anticipate future developments as retirement plans and expectations evolve.

Plan sponsors should be aware of the latest trends in fiduciary litigation to help manage the risk of being sued and, if sued, the risk of being liable. In my past two plan sponsor posts, Best Practices for Plan Sponsors #8 and #9, I discussed the lessons learned from the conditions in the settlement agreements for the Anthem and Vanderbilt cases. This article—about the BB&T settlement agreement—is another example of the importance of using appropriate share classes and a good process for selecting investments and monitoring service providers.

Continue reading Best Practices for Plan Sponsors #10

Share